An Opinion of Somebody Else

Home Contact Me

 



On July 30, 2009, a review on P. Woit's book Not Even Wrong was published on Amazon's site. (click here and search for the words "is right".) The Review which was writtes by by M. Page (Renton, WA, USA) contains the following paragraph:

"But the string community (or any other scientific group) cannot be allowed to turn their chosen approach into a fad, a cult, a religion or - worst - an inquisition. That might be sociologically amusing if it weren't so pernicious for physics and physicists. The effect is that physics departments become the monopoly of self-perpetuating, self-congratulating clans of homogenous thinkers. (Lee Smolin uses the psychological term "groupthink".) Young physicists are informed that string theory "is the only game in town". Sign up for it or go away."