germany 2009
There are more than 200,000 Jews in Germany, out of
a total population of 82.5 million. The largest Jewish centers are Berlin, Frankfurt, Munich
and Hamburg.
Antisemitic manifestations increased during Operation Cast
Lead, when activists from the extreme right, the extreme left and Islamic
fundamentalists took part in many virulently anti-Israel demonstrations (see General
Analysis 2009). The official total of 1,520 for 2009, released by the
Federal Ministry of the Interior, indicates a slight increase in the overall
number of antisemitic manifestations, albeit a significant decrease in violent
acts against Jews. This figure does not necessarily include the almost weekly
desecrations of Jewish cemeteries and Holocaust memorials all over Germany, which
for the most are recorded not as antisemitic crimes but as "vandalism.”[1]
On December 4, 2009, the Institute for Interdisciplinary
Research on Conflict and Violence (IKG), University of Bielefeld,
presented the findings of a survey which measured group focused enmity (Gruppenbezogene
Menschenfeindlichkeit) annually from 2002. Antisemitism constitutes one of
the ten elements of this phenomenon. In 2009, 16.5 percent of those polled
fully or partially agreed with the statement, "Jews have too much
influence in Germany"
compared to 21.6 percent in 2002, while 10.9 percent fully or partly agreed
with the statement, "Jews are also responsible for their own
persecution" (2002: 16.6 percent). While these findings show a decrease of
“classic” antisemitism, over the last seven years there has been a steady rise
in anti-Zionism and/or extreme anti-Israel attitudes which appear to have
partly replaced traditional antisemitic tropes. In his study, "The ‘New’
Anti-Semitism in Contemporary German Academia,"
Yves Pallade claims that in contrast to "traditional" antisemitism,
the new antisemitism − anti-Zionist rhetoric tainted by antisemitic
thinking − has become socially acceptable (gesellschaftsfaehig).
Stressing that the new antisemitism is a phenomenon found especially in
so-called politically correct academia, Pallade criticizes the reluctance of
decision-makers and opinion leaders to confront the problem.
Earlier, a conference at the University
of Jena, entitled "Modern
Antisemitism in Germany
– A Phenomenon of the Center?" discussed the notion that antisemitic
tendencies, frequently disguised as anti-Zionist rhetoric (principally focusing
on the nazificaton of the Jewish state), tend to be found not on the social
fringes but in the center. The attempt by left-wing activists to cancel a
showing in Germany of Claude Lanzmann's (director of Shoah) film Pourquoi
Israel (Why Israel) in October 2009 by setting up an imitation Israeli
checkpoint and shouting slogans such as Judenschweine (Jewish pigs) is
just one example out of hundreds that serves to demonstrate this idea (see General
Analysis 2009): They call it anti-Zionism, said Lanzmann, but it is
antisemitism.
Moreover, it is not Israeli policies that seem to be in the
center of what may be legitimate criticism but the very existence of Israel. Such
continuous propaganda and its acceptability in mainstream Germany has probably
encouraged the drastic rise in antisemitic manifestations, albeit most of them
verbal, as noted during Operation Cast Lead (see General
Analysis 2008/9). Thus, although there was a certain decrease in
antisemitic violence in 2009, Jews in Germany reported an increased sense
of insecurity. Many slogans
shouted or displayed during the demonstrations in January 2009 bore bluntly
antisemitic messages, mostly referring to the Holocaust. Placards showing the
swastika entwined with the Star of David were visible on streets throughout the
country. For example, during a 5,000-strong anti-Israel demonstration in Mainz
on January 10, 2009 during Operation Cast Lead, organized by the then unknown
Mainz Initiative for Peace in Gaza (supported
by Muslim organizations − http://www.fr-online.de/rhein-main/spezials/aerger-um-israel-fahne/-/1472874/2860042/-/index.html),
many protesters carried signs with slogans such as "Should Gaza become
Auschwitz?" and "Israel drinks the blood of our children." After
a small group of people waving an Israeli flag complained that they had been
attacked by protestors who shouted insults such as Ihr Judenschweine
(You Jewish pigs), the police determined that the flag was a provocation. At a
demonstration four days earlier in Berlin,
demonstrators carried signs such as "Death to Israel" or "Kick out the
Jews.” Similar violent anti-Israel and antisemitic incidents were recorded
during demonstrations throughout Germany.
Against the background of rising antisemitic tendencies among
Muslim immigrants, a panel discussion was held in Berlin, on February 23, 2009, during which
the Amadeu Antonio Foundation (AAS) (see
http://www.amadeu-antonio-stiftung.de/eng/about-us/) presented their latest
study, Die Juden sind Schuld. Antisemitismus in der
Einwanderungsgesellschaft am Beispiel muslimisch sozialisierter Mileus (The
Jews are guilty: Antisemitism in immigrant communities using the example of
Muslim socialized milieus). The panel discussion was based on the findings of
the 2007 survey “Muslims in Germany,” conducted by the Federal Ministry of the
Interior among Turkish Muslims, which found that Muslim pupils had
above-average tendencies toward antisemitic prejudices.
Heinz Fromm, head of the Federal Office for the Protection of
the Constitution (Bundesamt fuer Verfassungschutz), pointed toward
ideological similarities between neo-Nazis and extremist Muslim immigrants in Germany.
According to Fromm, right-wing extremists and Islamists share "a common
concept of the enemy: Israel
and the Jews overall." In contrast, Aiman Mazyek, general secretary of the
Central Council of Muslims in Germany,
stressed that the majority of Muslims in Germany know that there is "no
space for antisemitism in Islam." In 2009, 29 radical Islamist
organizations with 36,000 members, (more than 30,000 of Turkish origin), an
increase of about 5 percent were registered in Germany. (The federal interior
ministry put the number of Muslims in 2007 at 3.1−3.4 million, one
million with German citizenship.)
Both the Amadeu Antonio Foundation and the scientific journal
Focus Schule pointed to a rise in antisemitism among Muslim children and
teenagers: 15.7 percent of youngsters with a Muslim background agreed with the
statement, “Jews are greedy and arrogant.”
Right-wing extremism still
poses an increasing threat to the constitutional state. A survey among 45,000
ninth-graders, conducted in March 2009 by the Criminal
Research Center
in Hanover,
and published in a study called "Youth as Victims and Perpetrators of
Violence," showed that 6.4 percent held antisemitic views. The survey, in
which about 45,000 pupils were interviewed, revealed that 14 percent of German
teenagers thought that Jews deserved the Holocaust and one in 20 boys belonged
to far-right groups.
According to a poll
published in October 2009 by Der Spiegel, 13 percent of students at army
academies in Hamburg and Munich agreed with the political aims of the
"new rightists" and were sympathetic toward their ideas. They
believed the "national identity of Germany" was threatened by the
many foreigners living in the country. They also wanted a Germany led by
an elite and had doubts about the German parliamentary system.
In 2009, 195 (2008: 156)
extreme right-wing organizations and groups with a membership of 30,000 were
active in Germany.
This number includes members of the two racist, antisemitic and revisionist
extreme right parties under observation by the state authorities, the NPD (German National Democratic Party; 6,800
members) and the DVU (German Peoples’ Union; 4,500 members) (see
ASW 2006).
About 9,000 persons were categorized in 2009 by the police authorities as being
ready to use violence.
The NPD is the most
influential and active extreme right party in Germany. Lately, the party has been
trying to present itself as less threatening and more mainstream, by getting
involved in sports groups, youth centers and other community organizations. The
advance of women in the ranks is also helping to change its image. (For further
information on the modus operandi of the extreme right in Germany, see ASW 2008.)
Since the 1990s the number
of extreme right-wing women – those who advocate motherhood as well as those
who combat patriarchy and political ignorance among women – has been rising
steadily. In addition, a new and disturbing phenomenon detected by
anti-fascists is the attempt to indoctrinate young children by teachers and
guides, especially in the former communist East, which continues to grapple
with a strong neo-Nazi presence.
The government of the east
German state of Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania took the unusual step of ordering
anyone setting up a children's day-care center to pledge their support for Germany's democratic
constitution. The move followed a number of cases in which neo-Nazis had tried
to take over the running of a kindergarten, influence teaching in nurseries or
get recruited as teachers (http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/0,1518,716006,00.html).
The number of German
right-wing extremist postings to internet platforms aimed at school children or
music fans − Facebook, YouTube, Twitter and other social networking tools
like SchülerVZ, StudiVZ, MeinVZ, Wer-kennt-wen oder StayFriends −
escalated from 750 in
2007 to about 6,000 in
2009. This number could reach the tens of thousands with further monitoring,
observed Stefan Glaser, responsible for publishing data on right-wing extremism
on the website jugendschutz.net.
Right-wing extremists
disguise their material on mainstream social networks in order to attract the
unsuspecting. A CD, for example, with radically antisemitic lyrics was marketed
online as "Merkel's Bedtime Stories for Children aged 3-8." The CD,
adorned with the image of German chancellor Angela Merkel and containing 21
songs, denied the Holocaust and called for the murder of blacks and Jews.
http://forum.thiazi.net/showthread.php?p=1873529
After operators of Web 2.0
platforms began excluding clearly extreme right-wing users, the latter founded
their own communities on the net for like-minded people. The number of neo-Nazi
websites in Germany rose by 800
in the past year, bringing the total number to 1,872.
Despite a decrease of violent antisemitic crimes perpetrated
by extreme rightists, from 44
in 2008 to 31 to 2009, the total number of criminal
antisemitic acts motivated by ultra-right ideology rose from 1,496 to 1,520
(+1.6 percent). In Berlin alone the police registered 242 antisemitic offenses,
compared to 197 in
2008. As a consequence, federal minister of the interior Wolfgang Schaeuble
announced in August the formation of a panel which is mandated to make
recommendations to combat antisemitism. The panel, which is to report to the
government on a regular basis, is composed of experts from a variety of
backgrounds – both Jewish and non-Jewish.
On January 19, 2010, Arbeitstelle Rechtsextremismus
und Gewalt (ARUG) published a report on Antisemitism in Germany 2009. According
to the report, Holocaust memorial sites were desecrated in
Teterow/Mecklenburg-Vorpommern (January 11),Witten/Nordrhein-Westfalen (January
27), Waren/Mecklenburg-Vorpommern (March 3), Eisleben/Thüringen (March
10), Kassel/Hessen (May 23), Hellenthal-Blumenthal (May 30), Forst/Brandenburg
(July 29), Trier/Rheinland-Pfalz (September 14),
Stralsund/Mecklenburg-Vorpommern (October), Laatzen/Niedersachsen (November 12)
and Wesel/Nordrhein-Westfalen (December 16). The findings further stated that
cemeteries were desecrated among others in Unna (January 24), Spremberg
(January 29), Jebenhausen (April 22), Pforzheim (May 5), Dransfeld (June 1),
Düsseldorf (June 6), Wittenberg (June 17), Kronberg (November 11) and
Oschersleben (November 30).
In 2009 Jewish cemeteries were desecrated among others
in Unna (January 24), Spremberg (January 29), Jebenhausen (April 22), Pforzheim
(May 5), Dransfeld (June 1), Düsseldorf (June 6), Wittenberg (June 17),
Kronberg (November 11) and Oschersleben (November 30).